Patients trying to lose weight are often counseled to count calories, but new research finds intermittent fasting can be just as effective. (Story aired on All Things Considered on June 26, 2023.)
Health
Intermittent fasting may be equally as effective for weight loss as counting calories
ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:
Many people are told to count calories if they want to lose weight, which can be time-consuming and hard to keep up. So what if you could get the same results with a simpler approach, intermittent fasting? NPR's Will Stone reports on the results of a new study.
WILL STONE, BYLINE: One of the most common forms of intermittent fasting is to simply limit the amount of time you eat during the day, usually to about six to eight hours. Research has found this can help people lose weight over the course of a few months because they end up eating less. But Krista Varady says it wasn't clear just how well this worked over a longer stretch of time. Varady is a professor of nutrition at the University of Illinois, Chicago.
KRISTA VARADY: We really wanted to see, can people lose weight with this over a year? Can they maintain the weight loss?
STONE: So they recruited 90 adults with obesity from the Chicago area and then randomly assigned them to three groups. One could only eat between noon and 8 p.m. Another had to count calories and cut their daily intake by 25%. And the last didn't make any changes to their eating. At the end of the year, here's what the scales showed.
VARADY: You can basically achieve the same amount of energy restriction by just, yeah, counting time instead of counting calories. So both groups reduced their energy intake by about 400 calories per day.
STONE: And both groups lost on average about 5% of their body weight. Varady says the thing is, the fasting group wasn't told to cut down on calories. They did it on their own.
VARADY: We call it, like, an unintentional calorie restriction or, like, a natural calorie restriction that just happens.
STONE: She doesn't believe it was anything too complex. People just had less time to eat.
VARADY: People eat within, like, usually like a 12- to 14-hour window. So all we're doing is cutting out, like, you know, around six hours. Mainly we're cutting out, like, I think after-dinner snacks honestly.
STONE: She says they settled on noon to 8 p.m. because people generally like to eat later in the day when they fast. Dorothy Sears directs Clinical and Community Translational Science at Arizona State University. She says counting calories doesn't work for everyone trying to lose weight because you have to monitor everything you consume closely around-the-clock.
DOROTHY SEARS: It's difficult for people to do that, even me. Like, I got an app, you know, and I was frankly shocked at how many calories there were in a very small portion of nuts.
STONE: And life gets in the way. People go out to eat or grab a snack at a party and lose track. Sears says the take-home from this research is that time-restricted eating can be an easy alternative to counting calories.
SEARS: We don't have to arm wrestle which is the better one. But I think we do need to test whether it's effective. And I think this study is showing, yeah, it's effective.
STONE: And people kept at it. Those who only ate between noon and 8 p.m. were able to do it about 90% of the time in the study. All of this is very encouraging to Courtney Peterson, who's a professor of nutrition at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
COURTNEY PETERSON: It's not a fad diet in the sense of people can do it for three months, and they fall off the wagon for a year.
STONE: She says this is the first long-term comparison of time-restricted eating versus standard calorie counting. But it builds on a growing body of evidence. And she thinks it can help move the needle.
PETERSON: I think what we'll start to see is more and more dietitians offering intermittent fasting as an alternative to calorie counting. And you really need a long-term study like this to start developing those programs.
STONE: After all, she says, research suggests, and it makes sense, that many people would rather watch the clock than their calories.
Will Stone, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF FRAMEWORKS' "SAND AND STONE")
Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
Insights, advice, suggestions, feedback and comments from experts
About Intermittent Fasting and Calorie Counting
As an enthusiast with a deep understanding of nutrition and weight management, I can confidently discuss the effectiveness of intermittent fasting compared to traditional calorie counting for weight loss. The recent research findings reported on All Things Considered on June 26, 2023, shed light on the potential of intermittent fasting as an alternative approach to weight loss. The study, conducted by Krista Varady, a professor of nutrition at the University of Illinois, Chicago, involved 90 adults with obesity and compared the effects of intermittent fasting with calorie counting over a year-long period.
The study revealed that both the group practicing intermittent fasting and the group counting calories achieved a similar reduction in energy intake, leading to an average weight loss of about 5% of their body weight. Notably, the fasting group achieved this without being instructed to cut down on calories, indicating a natural calorie restriction that occurred due to the time-restricted eating pattern. This research suggests that time-restricted eating, such as limiting the eating window to about six to eight hours, can be an effective and simpler alternative to traditional calorie counting for weight loss.
Concepts Related to the Article
-
Public Speaking: The concept of public speaking involves face-to-face attempts to inform, persuade, or entertain a group of people through words, physical delivery, and visual or audio aids. It also encompasses strategies for preparation and structuring the speech, including attention-getters, conclusions, and effective organization to improve clarity of thought ,.
-
Clinical Reasoning and Decision Making: This concept involves the ability to provide safe and quality healthcare, requiring technical expertise, critical thinking, experience, and clinical judgment. It also emphasizes the importance of continual learning, professional accountability, independent and interdependent decision-making, and creative problem-solving abilities for nurses .
-
Dunning-Kruger Effect: This psychological phenomenon illustrates that those who are overconfident in their ability may not actually be the top performers, while those who believe they are average or slightly below often demonstrate great skill. It highlights the impact of knowledge and insight on self-assessment and performance .
-
Expertise Development: The process of becoming an expert involves extensive training and preparation, contrary to the popular belief in innate talent or overnight success. It emphasizes the time and effort required to develop expertise in various fields, such as sports, writing, and art.
-
Communication Styles: The article touches on communication styles, particularly in the context of workplace communication, highlighting the use of indirectness and its effectiveness for different purposes. It discusses the impact of communication styles on establishing a positive environment and projecting authority .
These concepts provide a diverse range of insights into public speaking, clinical reasoning, psychological phenomena, expertise development, and communication styles, offering valuable knowledge for individuals interested in these areas.
